Appointment Case Evaluation
- 1.The Appointment Case Review System for Research Fellows
- Appointment and Promotion Committees
Review Committee Committee Composition Review Type Meeting Schedule General Appointment and Promotion Committee The committee consists of 16 Academicians or Distinguished Research Fellows from Each of the Three Divisions Distinguished Employment For internal researchers nominated for a distinguished position, the deadline for submission is June 1 each year. External candidates will be reviewed on a rolling basis. 1. Appeal of Promotion
2. Reconsideration of Initial EmploymentThe meeting will be convened within one month after acceptance. Divisional Appointment and Promotion Committee The committee consists of nine to 15 Research Fellows or Individuals of Equivalent or Higher Rank 1.New Appointment Cases
2.Promotion Cases
3.Tenure Cases
4.Service Extension Cases
5.Special Extended Service (Second-Tenure) CaseMeetings will be held every two months, with the deadline for submission set on the fifth day of even-numbered months Promotion, Renewal, or Tenure Appeal Cases at the Institute or Research Center Level The meeting will be convened within one month after acceptance. - Review Criteria
- Legal Bases:
Article 6, The Guidelines for the Review of Initial Employment, Renewed Employment, Promotion or Distinguished Employment of Research Fellows of Academia Sinica and Supplementary Instructions for the Standards of Recruitment and Advancement of Research Fellows - Based on the Aforementioned Provisions:
The cases of initial employment, renewed employment, promotion and tenured employment of research fellows shall be reviewed based on the originality, rigor and importance of the candidate’s research achievements (including patents and technology transfer). The review criteria for cases of distinguished employment shall include academic research achievements and academic leadership. The candidate’s service achievements within and outside of Academia Sinica, including the contributions to public affairs at the institute (preparatory office) or research center and in Academia Sinica, academic and professional service within and outside of Academia Sinica including academic compilation and translation, thesis advising, participation in academic conferences and other professional lectures or policy recommendations, may also be included in the review. - Supplementary Instructions for the Standards of Recruitment and Advancement of Research Fellows
Rank Review Criteria Assistant Research Fellow (1) Research potential and previous academic achievements, AND (2) Compatibility of the candidate’s research with the development of the recruiting Institute or Research Center. Associate Research Fellow (1) Completed original research that addresses an important issue, AND (2) Demonstrated potential influence on the community in terms of research results or making a significant intellectual contribution to a collaborative research effort. Research Fellow (1) Completed significant and original work that addresses an important issue, AND (2) Demonstrated influence on the community in terms of research results or making a significant intellectual contribution to a collaborative research effort. Distinguished Research Fellow (1) Completed significant and sustained original work of world-class quality, AND (2) Demonstrated significant influence on the community in terms of research results, leading a collaborative research effort, or making a major intellectual contribution to a collaborative research effort. - Review Criteria for the Special Extended Service (Second-Tenure) Case
- Legal Bases:
- Checklist for Appointment Cases
- Related Regulations
- Qualifications
- Articles 6, 7, 8, 9, and 10, the Organization Regulations of the Research Institutes of Academia Sinica
- Appointment Term: Article 13, the Organization Regulations of the Research Institutes of Academia Sinica
- Review Procedures
- The Guidelines for the Review of Initial Employment, Renewed Employment, Promotion or Distinguished Employment of Research Fellows of Academia Sinica
- Extended Service Guidelines at Academia Sinica
- Supplementary Instructions for the Standards of Recruitment and Advancement of Research Fellows at Academia Sinica
- Conflict of Interest Guidelines for the Review of Appointment Cases at Academia Sinica
- Requirement to include a narrative summary of Research Accomplishments in tenure trackReappointment and Promotion cases.
- Required Documents
- Download Forms from the Personnel Office: Employment Review Form, Employment Review Opinion Form, Recommendation Letter from the Director
- Qualifications
- Appointment and Promotion Committees
- 2.The Appointment Case Review System for Research Specialists
- Review Committees
Review Committee Composition of the Committee Review Type Meeting Schedule Review Committee on Research Technical Personnel The committee consists of nine to 13 members with academic status or experience, and its member gender ratio shall adhere to the principle of at least one-third for each gender. 1. Initial Employment
2. Promotion
3. Extension
4. Research Technology Grant
5. Reconsideration of Initial EmploymentIn principle, a meeting will be convened when two or more appointment cases are received. Renewal or Promotion Appeal Cases at the Institute or Research Center Level The meeting will be convened within one month after acceptance. Appeal committee The President will appoint a Vice President to set up an appeal committee to handle the case. Appeal of Promotion The appeal committee shall meet within one month after the President receives the appeal. - Review Criteria
In accordance with Article 6 of the “Employment Review Guidelines for Academia Sinica Research Specialists,” when reviewing the employment case of research specialists, the candidate’s professional service content, professional achievements, and related administrative performance shall be reviewed. The technical ability of the candidate to support a research project and to develop new research equipment, new experimental methods, and innovative technologies should be as important considerations. The candidate’s contribution to the public affairs of Academia Sinica may also be included in the review. - Checklist for Appointment Cases
- Initial Employment
- Renewal or Promotion
- Related Regulations
- Qualifications, Appointment Term Regulations and Review Procedure
- Employment Review Guidelines for Academia Sinica Research Specialists
- Conflict of Interest Guidelines for the Review of Appointment Cases for Research Specialists at Academia Sinica
- Guidelines for the Establishment and Review of the Review Committee of Institution-wide Research Specialists, Academia Sinica
- Required Documents
- Download Forms from the Personnel Office:Employment Review Form, Employment Review Opinion Form, Recommendation Letter from the Director
- Qualifications, Appointment Term Regulations and Review Procedure
- Review Committees
